Safe Haven Insurance Agency

555 Broadhollow Rd, Melville, NY 11747, United States

Safe Haven Insurance Agency
Company Overview

Safe Haven Insurance Agency is a small family owned business. We provide boutique help to our clients and specialize in Life Insurance, Medicare and Annuities.
We love working with seniors and even help new retirees apply for Social Security at no charge.

Medicare is a maze and very difficult process for seniors to navigate. We help all seniors enroll in Medicare and find a plan that's best for their needs, weather it be a Medicare Supplement Plan, Medicare Advantage Plan or just a Drug Plan.

Life Insurance is another one of our passions! Helping seniors protect their loved ones with Final Expense Insurance or helping young families or business owners protect their loved ones.
Insurance is our business and we love helping our clients

Office Locations
Add review
Policyholder Reviews
Policyholder Review №1

James is fantastic!! He went above and beyond for my father in law. He is professional, friendly and looks out for his clients. James is also very easy to talk with. I highly recommend using him. Thanks for looking out for the family!

Policyholder Review №2

James of Safe Haven is the best. He genuinely cares about the people he helps. He was patient, informative & professional. He answered all our many questions & understood the complicated nuances of the insurance/Medicare industry & what plans would be best. Highly, highly recommended.

Policyholder Review №3

Policyholder Review №4

Very easy working with James @ Safe Haven Insurance Agency, thank you so much for your help.

Policyholder Review №5

James Donnelly was very helpful to myself and my husband. He spent hours helping us to compare and get the right insurance that was right for our needs., He even came to out house to help my husband with his. Because of high prices for my diabetes supplies he even recommended a company to help me with these at lower pricing. I would recommend him to all my aging family members and friends. Was very delightful to work with thanks again James Donnelly.

Policyholder Review №6

Very easy to speak with James Donnelly at Safe Haven. His explanations were concise and he was clearly looking for the most cost effective plans for us. So glad I called him.

Policyholder Review №7

I can’t say enough wonderful things about James Donnelly and how he immediately put me at ease. He was exactly the help and guidance I needed with my Medicare plan. He explained whatever I asked during the process and spent the time needed to help my confusion and I will highly recommend his service to anyone who needs help with Medicare plans. Thank you James!

Policyholder Review №8

James was extremely knowledgeable in all the Medicare plans and easily knew what would be the right one for me. I appreciate how quickly and smoothly it went. I highly recommend James and Safe Haven Insurance Agency

Policyholder Review №9

I had the good pleasure of working with Mr Donnelly at Safe Haven Insurance. James was very helpful, knowledgeable, willing to drill down on options & educating me on my opportunities. Working with James was a pleasure & very helpful getting to a good resolution. This is a man who cares, I highly recommend his services if needed!

Policyholder Review №10

James carefully walked me through the Medicare application process. I can't recommend him enough.

Policyholder Review №11

My husband and I were referred to James Donnelly by a friend. We could not have found a better person to help set us up with the right type of medical plans for our needs at this time. James was honest and patient with us every time we needed questions answered or something done in a timely manner. We would highly recommend him and have already referred him to friends & family.

Policyholder Review №12

James was an absolute pleasure to work with. He was so responsive and knowledgeable and helped my growing family find the best plan for us with ease. Thanks again James!

Policyholder Review №13

James listens attentively, assesses thoroughly, and recommends the policy that suits you best. I am grateful for the time he took to understand my needs and for presenting options tailored to serve me well. His kindness, professionalism, and expertise are exactly what I was looking for.

Policyholder Review №14

Absolutely easy to work with, easy to talk to and no pressure.

Policyholder Review №15

James is amazing to work with. Health Insurance is a murky place, so finding someone who will guide you with knowledge and integrity is critical - James is that individual!

Policyholder Review №16

You will never meet more knowlegeable or helpful people than James Donnelly and his team when it comes to medicare. If you are approaching 65, give James a call and learn about your options.

Policyholder Review №17

Worked with James on getting my mom insurance made the whole process easy, very pleasant and knowledgeable

Policyholder Review №18

James came to my house due to MY busy schedule.. He explained all the plans to my wife and I and we picked the best plan that fit our needs. It was a pleasure finally getting someone to explain this confusing insurance scenario to us.

Policyholder Review №19

Great guy who follows up makes you feel like family, along with great service highly recommended.

Policyholder Review №20

Very helpful helping me out. I will use them again.

Policyholder Review №21

With out a doubt, James has the patience of a saint! He searches every option that will work best for you, follows through and is extremely reachable! A great guy to have on your team 👍👍👍

Policyholder Review №22

My husband & I were so impressed by the knowledge and service that James provided us. Before meeting James we weren’t sure what to expect. You would be truly doing a disservice to yourself, if you didn’t make an appointment with James.

Policyholder Review №23

James is highly knowledgeable & professional! Highly recommend, you won’t be disappointed!

Policyholder Review №24

James I’m happy I saved the mailing from Safe Haven when it was time to go through the process of benefits. You were kind, patience, & professional and your knowledge directed me in the right direction with my situation. I would highly recommend James Donnelly to guide you with any insurance questions you might have.

Policyholder Review №25

Policyholder Review №26

Working with James at Safe Haven Insurance Agency was an extremely positive experience. I found James’s professionalism and knowledge to be second to none. James was able to get me multiple options for a specific Insurance policy that i have previously been denied. I would highly recommend James to anybody that is looking for insurance

Policyholder Review №27

James is great! He is knowledgeable, professional and a joy to work with. You feel guided all through the process.

Policyholder Review №28

Safe Haven Agency is great! James was very easy to work with he understood all of my needs and was able to relate to my situation. He made things very clear and I was able to understand the process. 10/10 I will refer to all my friends and family! Thank you Safe Haven!

Policyholder Review №29

I highly recommend Safe Haven Insurance Agency, James is professional hardworking knowledgeable and has great interpersonal relationship skills he promptly responded to my emails and phone calls, and he patiently answered my questions and took care of my specific insurance needs. Thank you

Policyholder Review №30

James really knows what he’s talking about and looked after my families needs… Thanks James I will recommend you to all my friends

Company Details
  • 2 photos
  • 30 reviews
  • 5.0 A.M. Best Rating
  • Claims Hotline: +1 631-608-1137
  • Official Website: https://www.safehaveninsuranceagency.com/
  • Corporate Headquarters: 555 Broadhollow Rd, Melville, NY 11747, United States
  • Geo Coordinates: 40.7634578, -73.4225172
Insurance Products
  • Insurance agency
Business Hours
  • Monday: 8 AM–8 PM
  • Tuesday: 8 AM–8 PM
  • Wednesday: 8 AM–8 PM
  • Thursday: 8 AM–8 PM
  • Friday: 8 AM–8 PM
  • Saturday: 8 AM–1 PM
  • Sunday: Closed
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair-accessible car park: Available
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance: Available